From: Reported municipal costs from outdoor smoke-free by-laws-experience from Ontario, Canada
# | Question | Prompts |
---|---|---|
The first few questions ask about resources allocated towards bylaw promotion and awareness. | ||
1. | Did the community use signs to communicate the new bylaw? How many? Do you know how much it cost to produce and post those signs? | |
2. | Did staff do presentations? To whom? | |
3. | Did the community use pamphlets, brochures and/or posters to communicate the new bylaw? How many? Do you know the cost to print and post these? | |
4. | Did the community hold public meetings? Do you know how many? Was there a cost associated with these meetings? | |
5. | Were any other resources used to promote the new bylaw? | What is the approximate number of each of the following resources that were allocated towards promotion and awareness of (Bylaw No.): |
◦ Signs? | ||
◦ Presentations? | ||
◦ Pamphlets/Brochures/Posters? | ||
◦ # of Public Town/City/Municipal Meetings held? | ||
◦ Other (Please Specify): | ||
6. | What is the approximate cost of each of the following resources that were allocated towards promotion and awareness of (Bylaw No.): | ◦ Signs? |
◦ Presentations? | ||
◦ Pamphlets/Brochures? | ||
◦ Public Town/City/Municipal Meetings held? | ||
◦ Other (Please Specify): | ||
The next few questions ask who is responsible for enforcing the outdoor smoke-free bylaw in your municipality, their enforcement approach, and the number of warnings and tickets that have been issued. | ||
7. | In your municipality, who is designated to enforce the bylaw? | |
____ Bylaw Enforcement Officer for Municipality | ||
____ Local police service | ||
____ Tobacco Enforcement Officer from the Health Unit | ||
____ Combination of both – Please explain: | ||
8. | The next question asks you to describe your municipality’s enforcement approach. Please indicate if your approach incudes any of the following: | |
_____ Routine inspections | ||
_____ Responding to complaints | ||
_____ Other – Please specify: | ||
9. | How many warnings have been issued since the implementation of (Bylaw No.)? Did your community have a set period of time where there was a policy of issuing warnings instead of tickets – or other grace period? [yes/no] – if yes, for how long? | [It’s possible many places had a phase-in period where they did warnings for some time? If this was the practice that should be identified] |
10. | How many tickets have been issued since the implementation of (Bylaw No.)? How many of these tickets/fines have been challenged in municipal courts or other appeal processes? | |
11. | In terms of resources allocated to your city/municipality’s enforcement staff: How many additional bylaw officers were hired as a result of the implementation of (Bylaw No.) in terms of Full-Time Equivalents (FTE)? | |
12. | Did your municipality re-allocate resources initially to enforce this by-law during its roll-out? | |
13. | How much additional cost was allocated towards enforcement staff (e.g. for hiring, salaries) as a result of the implementation of (Bylaw No.)? | |
The next few questions deal with public satisfaction and support for (Bylaw No.) including calls to the Tobacco Information Line or other methods of reporting complaints. | ||
14. | For your health unit, how many calls have you received to the Tobacco Information Line to address public complaints associated with (Bylaw No.) or outdoor smoking in general? | Are you able to tell how me many of these complains are from multiple sources or the sample people calling multiple times? |
Have there been any calls to the Tobacco Information Line in support of (Bylaw No.)? | ||
15. | Is there another method by which people can submit a complaint? If yes, what is this method? | How many complaints have been received by this method associated with (Bylaw No.) or outdoor smoking in general? |